← All years

2004

6 ranked · 4 mentions

Album of the year

Leviathan

Mastodon

Sludge MetalPick: Hearts Alive

Ranked

  1. 1

    Leviathan

    Mastodon

    Sludge MetalPick: Hearts Alive

  2. 2

    Panopticon

    ISIS

    Avant-garde/Post MetalPick: In Fiction

  3. 3

    Once

    Nightwish

    Symphonic MetalPick: Ghost Love Score

  4. 4

    Eppur Si Muove

    Haggard

    Symphonic MetalPick: Eppur Si Muove

  5. 5

    The Human Equation

    Ayreon

    Progressive MetalPick: Voices

  6. 6

    Demigod

    Behemoth

    Death MetalPick: The Reign Ov Shemsu-Hor

Honorable mentions

Albums we love just as much — kept here as favorites beyond the ranked list.

← 2003All years2005 →